Big Cartel vs Sellfy: which fits your store?

Last verified 2026-08-29 some data medium/low confidence

Big Cartel and Sellfy are both ecommerce platform tools compared here on pricing verified 2026-08-29, published plans, App Store standing, and themes from recent merchant reviews. Big Cartel starts cheaper (free vs $29/mo); Big Cartel has a free tier, Sellfy does not. — auto-generated from tracked data; editorial verdict pending.

How do Big Cartel and Sellfy compare?

	Big Cartel	Sellfy
App Store rating	—	—
Price from	free	$29/mo
Free tier	✓ yes	✗ no
Published plans	3	4
Data confidence	medium	high

What would you actually pay?

Big Cartel plans

Plan	Monthly	Limits / notes
Gold (Free)	$0	Limited features
Platinum	$15	7 days free trial, then $15/mo
Diamond	$30	No commitment, cancel anytime

Verified 2026-08-08 from vendor pricing page.

Sellfy plans

Plan	Monthly	Limits / notes
Starter	$29	Up to $10k in annual sales; 10GB maximum product file size; 2,000 free email marketing credits.
Business	$79	Up to $50k in annual sales; 15GB maximum product file size; 10,000 free email marketing credits.
Premium	$159	Up to $200k in annual sales; 20GB maximum product file size; 50,000 free email marketing credits.
High-volume sellers	—	For sellers exceeding $200k in annual sales.

Prices are shown in USD. Yearly billing saves 25%. PayPal or Stripe processing fees are additional, typically 2.9% + $0.30. Revenue exceeding a plan limit may incur a 2% overage fee if the account is not upgraded.

Verified 2026-08-29 from vendor pricing page.

FAQ

Which is cheaper, Big Cartel or Sellfy?

Big Cartel starts lower at free, vs $29/mo for Sellfy (verified 2026-08-29).

Does Big Cartel or Sellfy have a free plan?

Big Cartel has a free tier; Sellfy does not publish one.

Which is rated higher on the Shopify App Store?

App Store ratings are shown in the table above where available.

How we compare: pricing and plans are collected automatically from vendor pages on a schedule and shown with verification dates; ratings come from the Shopify App Store; merchant sentiment is synthesized from the most recent App Store reviews (paraphrased, never quoted). We currently have no affiliate relationship with either vendor. Found an error? The data snapshot behind this page is dated — check the vendor's page for same-day changes.

Related comparisons

Big Cartel vs Adobe Commerce (Magento) · Big Cartel vs BigCommerce · Big Cartel vs Ecwid · Big Cartel vs Fourthwall · Big Cartel vs Medusa · Big Cartel vs Saleor